Deleted Posts are Discoverable

An article about using deleted posts in social networking sites for legal proceedings, an interesting caution:

" ... Deleted Facebook and MySpace Posts Are Discoverable--Romano v. Steelcase

On my personal blog, I have repeatedly blogged about plaintiffs who tell one story in court only to have that story undone by their postings to social networking sites. See, e.g., Sedie v. US, People v. Franco (despite the tragedy, my personal favorite) and Embry v. State.

This case is in the same vein. Romano claims that she is largely bedridden/housebound, but her public Facebook pictures show her apparently enjoying herself away from home. The defense requests access to her non-public posts on Facebook and MySpace, which the judge grants.

The short opinion focuses on the defense's ability to access the private posts, but the actual order covers both current as well as deleted material. Specifically, the court orders "Defendant STEELCASE's motion for an Order granting said Defendant access to Plaintiff's current and historical Facebook and MySpace pages and accounts, including all deleted pages and related information, is hereby granted in all respects." The court didn't discuss the deleted material separately in its analysis, but this seems like a gotcha. Once a person posts material to Facebook or MySpace, there may not be a meaningful "undo"--even deleting it does not eliminate the material as future discoverable evidence for the duration of Facebook's and MySpace's retention periods. ... "