/* ---- Google Analytics Code Below */
Showing posts with label Patents. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Patents. Show all posts

Monday, May 15, 2023

Google: AI should never be credited as an inventor

Credit, Invention and the Future use of builder on invention you can build on in a kind of open source.

Google: AI should Never be Credited as an Inventor 

The company responded to an open question from the U.S. Patent Office.

By Mark Sullivan  in FastCompany

Google says that generative AI systems should not be listed as an inventor even if the an AI system made a significant contribution to the invention, Axios reports.

“As our comments say, we believe A.I. should not be labeled as an inventor under the U.S. Patent Law, and believe people should hold patents on innovations brought about with the help of AI,” Google senior patent counsel Laura Sheridan told Axios.

The company gave its opinion on the matter in a filing to the U.S. Patent Office. The USPTO had called for a opinions on a set of questions related to generative AI and patents. In particular, the office asked: “If an AI system contributes to an invention at the same level as a human who would be considered a joint inventor, is the invention patentable under current patent laws?”

Generative AI systems are already inventing novel combinations of drug compounds for treating disease. And as the systems improve, and are given access to more specialized knowledge bases, they could be the rightful inventor of something with no assistance from humans at all.

Should such inventions be credited to AIs? Or should be they be credited to the companies that created the AI? The Commerce Department and the USPTO need establish a position on the matter. If they change the USPTO’s current rules, it could have profound effects on the country’s innovation ecosystem, which relies on patents to make sure that inventions pay off in dollars.

Kathi Vidal, Under Secretary of Commerce for Intellectual Property and Director of the USPTO, has indicated that she’d like to clarify the government’s position on inventor status for AIs this year.

A U.S. Court of Appeals recently ruled that patents are reserved for human inventors. The Supreme Court last week refused to hear the case, leaving the decision of the lower court in place. The courts will very likely be asked to revisit the issue.  ... ' 


Saturday, November 05, 2022

IBM Watson AI Patent Assistant

Mentioned earlier, examining. 

IBM Watson Demos AI Patent Assistant

ERIC HAL SCHWARTZ on October 31, 2022 at 4:00 pm in Voicebot.ai

IBM and the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) are testing a new AI tool for exploring and analyzing intellectual property data. The IBM IP Advisor uses Watson’s conversational AI to help people look for patents, both submitted and granted, to help inventors avoid potential rejection for repetition and spot where their ideas would fit.

AI PATENT DIVE

Inventors need to know about patents that may overlap with their own ideas, information known as ‘prior art.’ The sheer volume of patents and applications makes assessing the prior art difficult without enormous resources or expertise in patent law. The IBM IP Advisor leverages Watson’s natural language processing to rapidly gather and analyze patent information based on questions posed by a user about patents, application statuses, and what kind of refinements they might need to make to their inventions to avoid repeating or infringing on someone else’s intellectual property. The service is available for public testing until the end of November on the USPTO’s Open Data Portal.

“Prior art research and analysis is the foundation of a successful product or service launch, but the growth of prior art coupled with the need for appropriate keywords and the right patent classifications can be a barrier to entry for the every-day inventor,” IBM’s general manager for the U.S. public and federal market Steve LaFleche said. “I’m proud of our work with the USPTO in support of their objective to not just deploy smarter technology, but to build a better, more accessible IP system.”  ... ' 

Monday, October 31, 2022

Watson as an IP and Patent Advisor

Could have used this in the enterprise and with US Government work some time ago ... talked this and Watson Discovery with IBM, seemed to lay fallow for some time.   Demos?

IBMAnnounces Demonstration Project with U.S. Patent and Trademark Office to Help Make Patent Research Insights More Accessible and Usable

NEWS PROVIDED BY  IBM 

Oct 31, 2022, 09:00 ET

WASHINGTON, Oct. 31, 2022 /PRNewswire/ -- IBM (NYSE: IBM) today announces a demonstration project with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) to test an artificial intelligence (AI) driven intellectual property (IP) analysis tool, the IBM IP Advisor with Watson® Demonstration System. Leveraging conversational AI technology with IBM Watson Assistant, and content insight mining and guided navigation solutions with IBM Watson Discovery, the system is designed to help users more efficiently uncover and analyze relevant patent data, allowing more time for strategic, value-added tasks.

Information known publicly before the actual filing date of a U.S. patent application, such as currently held and similar U.S. patents and published patent applications, is called prior art. When an inventor has an idea for a new product, a prior art study can be helpful in understanding the landscape of the field of invention by assessing not only prior art, but also competitors and opportunities for innovation in the field. However, with the continued rise in the number of patent applications being filed and the increasing volume of patent data, finding relevant, accurate information and analyzing prior art can be difficult and time consuming – especially for new inventors, 'Main Street' retailers and consumers not steeped in patent law. IBM aims to help address this challenge and promote greater participation in the innovation process with the IBM IP Advisor with Watson® Demonstration System.

By enabling natural language processing of queries with IBM Watson Discovery technology, the Demonstration System can help users locate relevant information using their own terminology, without the need to use specific terms and complex methods. And leveraging IBM Watson Assistant conversational AI technology as a guide, users can ask questions of embedded virtual agents to further inform and optimize their patent analysis.

The IBM IP Advisor with Watson® Demonstration System uses a subset of publicly obtainable U.S. patent data and is available for public testing and feedback on the USPTO's Open Data Portal through November 30, 2022.

"Prior art research and analysis is the foundation of a successful product or service launch, but the growth of prior art coupled with the need for appropriate keywords and the right patent classifications can be a barrier to entry for the every-day inventor," said Steve LaFleche, general manager, U.S. public and federal market for IBM. "I'm proud of our work with the USPTO in support of their objective to not just deploy smarter technology, but to build a better, more accessible IP system."  ... 

Tuesday, October 25, 2022

Further Upheld: AIs Cant Hold Patents

Recall we examined this for a Govt client, her some additional implications.

AI News

US court upholds ruling that AIs can’t be patent holders

By Ryan Daws | October 21, 2022 | TechForge Media

Categories: Artificial Intelligence, Ethics & Society, Legislation & Government,

The US Court of Appeals has upheld previous rulings that AIs cannot hold patents for inventions.

AIs are increasingly being used to make new discoveries but, under most patent laws, a human must be listed as the patent holder for inventions.

Dr Stephen Thaler created a device called DABUS that consists of neural networks and has been used to invent an emergency warning light, a food container that improves grip and heat transfer, and more. Thaler believes that AIs should be patent holders and has launched numerous cases in at least 15 countries to argue the case.

So far, the cases in the UK, US, and New Zealand have all been rejected.

In August 2021, an Australian federal court ruled that AI systems can be credited as inventors. However, in April 2022 that decision was reversed.

Ryan Abbott, a professor at the University of Surrey, filed the applications in Australia on behalf of Dr Thaler., “If I teach my PhD student and they go on to make a final complex idea, that doesn’t make me an inventor on their patent, so it shouldn’t with a machine,” Abbott told the Wall Street Journal in 2019.

In the US, the case was submitted by the Artificial Inventor Project (AIP) which argued that Thaler has no experience in consumer goods and would not have created them himself. Once again, it was rejected.

“This is a case in which the question of statutory interpretation begins and ends with the plain meaning of the text … [T]here is no ambiguity: the Patent Act requires that inventors must be natural persons; that is, human beings,” wrote Judge Leonard P. Stark in the court’s ruling.

At the time, Thaler and Abbott said they’d continue appealing the decisions.

“It ignores the purpose of the Patent Act and the outcome that AI-generated inventions are now unpatentable in the United States,” Abbott told Bloomberg Law.

“That is an outcome with real negative social consequences.”

While the appeal rejections haven’t deterred Thaler or Abbott, most courts appear set on maintaining the principle that humans can only be listed as inventors. The primary argument of the courts is that no AI is creating a new invention by itself, it’s a tool that’s ultimately acting on the instruction of a human. Until we achieve general artificial intelligence, it’s a position that’s hard to dispute.

Of the latest rejection, Thaler is requesting a rehearing at the Federal Circuit level.   ... ' 

Wednesday, August 24, 2022

US Inventors must be Human

 Formerly covered here.   Appeal to Supreme court likely follows.  Is this important enough?

Inventors Must Be Human, Federal Court Rules in Blow to AI

By Bloomberg Law, August 10, 2022

Computer scientist Stephen Thaler was dealt a blow in his battle for artificial intelligence machines to be recognized as inventors on patents, after the United States' top patent court found that inventors must be humans.

The term "individual" in the Patent Act refers only to humans, meaning an AI doesn't count as an inventor on a patentable invention, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit ruled Friday (August 5).   The decision lines up with courts in the European Union, the United Kingdom, and Australia that have refused to accept Thaler's argument. His only currently existing win is from a South African court that said an AI can be a patent inventor.

Unless the U.S. Supreme Court steps in, the Federal Circuit is typically the final authority on U.S. patent matters. Thaler plans to appeal to U.S. Supreme Court, his attorney said.  ...

From Bloomberg Law

Tuesday, July 05, 2022

UK Says No to AI Patents

Contrary to the US it currently seems.  Worked in the IP/Patent space for some time. 

UK decides AI still cannot patent inventions  By Chris Vallance in the BBC, Technology reporter

The UK's Intellectual Property Office has decided artificial-intelligence systems cannot patent inventions for the time being.

Patents assign the ownership of a new invention to its creator. A recent IPO consultation found many experts doubted AI was currently able to invent without human assistance.   Current law allowed humans to patent inventions made with AI assistance, the government said, despite "misperceptions" this was not the case.

Last year, the Court of Appeal ruled against Stephen Thaler, who had said his Dabus AI system should be recognised as the inventor in two patent applications, for:   a food container,    a flashing light

The judges sided, by a two-to-one majority, with the IPO, which had told him to list a real person as the inventor.

"Only a person can have rights - a machine cannot," wrote Lady Justice Laing in her judgement.

"A patent is a statutory right and it can only be granted to a person."

But the IPO also said it would "need to understand how our IP system should protect AI-devised inventions in the future" and committed to advancing international discussions, with a view to keeping the UK competitive.  ... ' 

Friday, September 10, 2021

US Takes Stance in Patents by an Computer Using AI

In a previous effort I took a look at intellectual property law as used by the USAF.  What is noted here are initial rulings by US courts.  These, as it mentions, are being appealed.  Note that an oath has to be taken by a human in this case, what is the equivalent of a machine 'Oath' taken by an AI?   Continues to evolve by patent laws in other countries.

Only Humans, Not AI Machines, Get a U.S. Patent, Judge Rules

in Bloomberg, Susan Decker, September 3, 2021

U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema in Alexandria, VA, has ruled that only an actual human can be listed as an inventor on patents under U.S. law, while a computer using artificial intelligence (AI) cannot. Brinkema ruled that under federal law, an "individual," defined as a natural person, is required to take an oath that they are the inventor on a patent application. The case involved the Artificial Inventor Project at the U.K.'s University of Surrey, which has undertaken a global effort to have a computer named as an inventor. Courts in South Africa and Australia have ruled in the project's favor. University of Surrey's Ryan Abbott said the U.S. ruling will be appealed, along with those in the U.K. and Europe. Said Abbott, "We believe listing an AI as an inventor is consistent with both the language and purpose of the Patent Act."  ... ' 

Sunday, February 28, 2021

Universities Capturing More Value from Research

 Sounds akin to our own work on gathering value from research.   Our recent work with the DOD to understand what research it has paid for, and can be monetized or placed into public use.  Good discussion. 

Should Universities Try to Capture More Value from Their Research?  Knowledge@Wharton

Supports K@W's  Innovation Content

A pair of newly published research papers co-authored by Wharton management professor David H. Hsu benchmark and explore commercialization drivers of academic science. The papers find that university research has produced pathbreaking innovations across many disciplines, many of which have been commercialized successfully. Yet, on average, universities capture 16% of the value they help create through licensing revenues or equity stakes in the startups their research spawns. Furthermore, some researchers and universities are much better able to commercialize their discoveries compared to others, even holding constant the discovery itself.

The first research paper, which Hsu wrote with Po-Hsuan Hsu, Tong Zhou and Arvids A. Ziedonis, is titled “Benchmarking U.S. University Patent Value and Commercialization Efforts: A New Approach” and was published this month in Research Policy. The second paper, “Revisiting the Entrepreneurial Commercialization of Academic Science: Evidence from ‘Twin’ Discoveries,” co-authored with Matt Marx, is forthcoming in Management Science.

The results suggest that universities with policies and resources devoted to commercialization efforts, aided by academic staff with commercialization experience and which are more interdisciplinary, are much more successful at translating research for commercial outcomes. Consequently, Hsu and his co-authors make a case for universities to take a closer look at the value they are extracting by commercializing their patents and intellectual property.... ' 

Monday, January 25, 2021

Intellectual Property Analysis

 Connects to some of my recent work.   Categorizing and usefully measuring what we have. 

Google proposes applying AI to patent application generation and categorization

By Kyle Wiggers   in Venturebeat

Google asserts that the patent industry stands to benefit from AI and machine learning models like BERT, a natural language processing algorithm that attained state-of-the-art results when it was released in 2018. In a whitepaper published today, the tech giant outlines a methodology to train a BERT on over 100 million patent publications from the U.S. and other countries using open-source tooling, which can be used to determine the novelty of patents and generate classifications to assist with categorization.

The global patent corpus is large, with millions of new patents issued every year. It’s complex, as well. Patent applications average around 10,000 words and are meticulously wordsmithed by inventors, lawyers, and patent examiners. Patent filings are also written with language that can be unintelligible to lay readers and highly context dependent; many terms are used to mean completely different things in different patents.  ....  

Wednesday, August 26, 2020

P&G among Others Lead Patents in 3D Printing

Was unaware that my former employer, P&G, was so involved in the patenting, innovation and use of 3D printing capabilities:

Future of 3D Printing Is in U.S., Europe Patenting
Bloomberg
By Susan Decker; Ryan Beene
July 14, 2020

A study by the European Patent Office (EPO) found that the U.S. and Europe are spearheading innovation in three-dimensional (3D) printing, which is the fastest-growing technology field. The agency determined that established multinationals like General Electric, Airbus, Johnson & Johnson, and Procter & Gamble are producing the majority of 3D printing-related patents. However, 20% of new 3D printing-related European patents are owned by small companies, and another 10% by universities; top patent recipients among research institutions include Harvard University, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and the University of California. EPO's Antonio Campino said the boom in 3D printing reflects the rapid growth of digital technologies overall.  ... "

Wednesday, April 29, 2020

US Patent Office Says AI Cannot be an Inventor

Relates to some work underway.

US patent office rules that artificial intelligence cannot be a legal inventor

Only ‘natural persons’ need apply     By Jon Porter@JonPorty in TheVerge

The US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has ruled that artificial intelligence systems cannot be credited as an inventor in a patent, the agency announced earlier this week. The decision came in response to two patents — one for a food container and the other for a flashing light — that were created by an AI system called DABUS.

Among the USPTO’s arguments is the fact that US patent law repeatedly refers to inventors using humanlike terms such as “whoever” and pronouns like “himself” and “herself.” The group behind the applications had argued that the law’s references to an inventor as an “individual” could be applied to a machine, but the USPTO said this interpretation was too broad. “Under current law, only natural persons may be named as an inventor in a patent application,” the agency concluded. .... " 

Artificial Inventor Project: http://artificialinventor.com/patent-applications/
DABUS/Creativity Machine: http://imagination-engines.com/iei_dabus.php


Friday, November 29, 2019

Preventing Theft By Drones

Brief,  intriguing piece in Coindesk, a blockchain App of the tracking type.   Seems a very simple solution regarding altitude and IOT.    No indication anything is currently being created.

IBM Patents Blockchain to Stop Drones From Stealing Packages in Coindesk

Amazon, DHL and FedEx are building drones that deliver packages to your door. IBM, however, envisions a future where drones steal them instead. 

The computing giant won a patent on Nov. 12 for “Preventing anonymous theft by drones” with an Internet of Things (IoT) altimeter that triggers upon liftoff, tracking the package’s altitude and uploading the data to a blockchain platform.

The patent seeks to get ahead of two modern realities: people buy goods online, and people fly their own personal drones. That could be a problem, it says, if the trends combine to devious ends. 

“The confluence of the increase in drone use and the increase in online shopping provides a situation in which a drone may be used with nefarious intent to anonymously take a package that is left on a doorstep after delivery,” the patent description reads.

IBM’s solution is to outfit packages with an IoT sensor that only triggers if it detects a change in altitude “exceeding the threshold … expected when the object is lifted away by a drone.” Once it does, the sensor periodically updates the blockchain, and the intended recipient, with the package’s altitude. 

To be clear, there’s no indication that IBM actually plans to build an operational device. And if it does, it may well swap out a blockchain for some other “secure database,” according to the patent  ... " 

Wednesday, November 06, 2019

US Patent Office to Leverage AI

US Patent office to use AI Methods

Patent Office Seeks Help From AI   By The Wall Street Journal

The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office is expanding its use of artificial intelligence.

The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) is expanding its use of artificial intelligence (AI) to handle a steadily increasing number of patent applications, including an influx of AI-related filings.

The agency is currently looking for an AI expert who will advise on state-of-the-art implementations of smart tools in its internal business units, while creating guidelines for using AI to drive efficiencies in both the patent and trademark process.

The overall goal is to speed up the process, in part by automating aspects of the research performed by staff examiners and supervisors.

The agency received about 3,800 AI-related patent applications in 2018, up from about 3,200 in 2017 and 1,900 in 2014.

Said USPTO director Andrei Iancu,“Our need is high and technology has advanced, so this is a good time to take advantage of these new tools to help our examiners.”

From The Wall Street Journal
View Full Article: https://www.wsj.com/articles/patent-office-seeks-help-from-ai-11572297295

Saturday, August 24, 2019

Qualcomm Won't Have to Offer Patent Licenses Yet

Intriguing insight to antitrust vs patent licensing.  Note the embedded predictive aspect included here.  Predicting Qualcomm's income from patent licensing?

Qualcomm won't have to offer patent licenses to rivals, for now
A court has granted a partial reprieve from a US antitrust ruling.
 BY Jon Fingas, @jonfingas in Engadget

Qualcomm won't face the full consequences of the antitrust ruling, at least not right away. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has granted a request to temporarily halt requirements that it both grant patent licenses to rivals and stop demanding patent licenses before customers can buy chips. The stay will only last as long as Qualcomm's appeal of the antitrust case wends its way through the courts, but Qualcomm was convinced the original decision "will be overturned."

The company claimed the reprieve was vital to investing in technologies as part of a "critical time of transition to 5G."

Of course, there's a more pragmatic factor behind the request: the ruling would have dramatically altered Qualcomm's existing patent strategy. Reuters noted that Qualcomm would have to renegotiate all of its current chip and patent deals, and any new deals would need to honor stricter requirements. Those could require extensive work and likely hurt Qualcomm's substantial income from patent licenses.   .... " 

Monday, August 05, 2019

Future of Patent Law When AI's Invent

Recently posted about the implications of AI's being allowed to be cited as inventors.   The following article in TechExplore further looks at how this could influence patent law, also country by country implications.  All in a flux, but this gives some starting points.

Two AI-led inventions poke at future of patent law
by Nancy Cohen ,  Techexplore

A University of Surrey-based team have filed the first patent applications for inventions created by a machine. Applications were made to the US, EU and UK patent offices; they are for a machine using artificial intelligence as the inventor of two ideas for a beverage container and a flashing light.  ... " 

Thursday, August 01, 2019

Recognizing AI as an Inventor

I don't think the US patent system, at least,  is ready for this kind of thing

AI system 'should be recognised as inventor'   By Leo Kelion in the BBC

An artificial intelligence system should be recognised as the inventor of two ideas in patents filed on its behalf, a team of academics says.

The AI has designed interlocking food containers that are easy for robots to grasp and a warning light that flashes in a rhythm that is hard to ignore.

Patents offices insist innovations are attributed to humans - to avoid legal complications that would arise if corporate inventorship were recognised.   The academics say this is "outdated".

And it could see patent offices refusing to assign any intellectual property rights for AI-generated creations.  As a result, two professors from the University of Surrey have teamed up with the Missouri-based inventor of Dabus AI to file patents in the system's name with the relevant authorities in the UK, Europe and US.  .... '

Wednesday, April 03, 2019

Healthcare Patent for Sale

Via IdeaConnection:  Click through for details ....

Method and Apparatus of Remotely-operated Automated External Defibrillator Incorporated into a Handheld Device

AED mobile defibrillator. A rescue cell apparatus used for cardiac defibrillation of a patient, the apparatus comprising: a hand held device for sending and receiving communication signals and configured to be used as a remote control to administer a defibrillation pulse to the patient for cardiac defibrillation; a defibrillator unit having a sensor electronic pad position able on the patient, the sensor electronic pad adapted to deliver the defibrillation pulse; and a second electronic pad, connectable by an electrical wire to the defibrillator unit, the second electronic pad position able on the patient and adapted to detect ECG signals and to deliver the defibrillation pulse to the patient; and an image recognition module configured in the handheld device, and adapted to Verify positioning of the sensor electronic pad and the second electronic pad on the patient before defibrillation.

Patents:
US 9,737,723 issued 2017-08-22   

Type of Offer: Sale   ....

Saturday, March 23, 2019

AI and Patents in the WIPO

In a meeting a few weeks ago I asked the question about how findings using AI methods were being protected,  and got a somewhat unclear answer.    This perhaps shows why. Here much more about what is happening in this space.  Interesting stats about directions. - Franz

Based on the:WIPO (World Intellectual Property Organization) Trends Report  (158 page PDF) 

AI and patents - trends to watch  from the WIPO technology trends report
WIPO Technology Trends report 2019  came as a surprise to me. We in AI are not used to thinking about patents so much because tools / platforms are mostly Open sourced.

Here are the key takeaways from this report:
AI and patents - trends to watch  from the WIPO technology trends report.Posted by Ajit Jaokar in the DSC

The ratio of scientific papers to inventions has decreased from 8:1 in 2010 to 3:1 in 2016 – indicative of a shift from theoretical research to the use of AI technologies in commercial products and services.
Among AI functional applications, computer vision, which includes image recognition, is the most popular. Computer vision is mentioned in 49 percent of all AI-related patents (167,038 patent documents), growing annually by an average of 24 percent (21,011 patent applications filed in 2016).  

functional applications with the highest growth rates in patent filings in the period 2013 to 2016 were AI for robotics and control methods, which both grew on average by 55 percent a year.  
Many AI patents include inventions that can be applied in different industries – telecommunications, transportation , medical sciences , personal devices, computing and human–computer interaction (HCI) featured highly in the related industries.  ...."   (Considerably more at the link)

Sunday, February 03, 2019

AI Patents Surge

Huge Surge in AI Patent Applications in Past 5 Years 
Financial Times   By Clive Cookson

The World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) has estimated that the past five years witnessed a major boom in artificial intelligence (AI), with more than 50% of all patents filed since 2013. From 2013 and 2017, global AI-related patent applications surged from 18,995 to 55,660; IBM and Microsoft owned the biggest AI patent portfolios, with 8,290 and 5,930 patents, respectively. According to WIPO director-general Francis Gurry, the patent explosion "means we can expect a very significant number of new AI-based products, applications, and techniques that will alter our daily lives—and also shape future human interaction with the machines we created." Meanwhile, the proportion of scientific papers to inventions declined from 8:1 in 2010 to 3:1 in 2016, suggesting theoretical research has been overtaken by commercial AI use. Machine learning is the most frequently disclosed AI technique in patents, and computer vision is the most popular functional application. ... " 

Monday, June 19, 2017

Anti Showrooming Patent

Wondering various aspects of this.

In ChainStore Age, requires registration.

Amazon granted anti-showrooming patent
Despite the many sales that showrooming has afforded Amazon over the years, the retailer surely doesn't want to become a victim going forward. ... " 

(UpDate) More in Retailwire on this Amazon Patent, with discussion.